What is Market Value? Depending on who you ask, you’ll get a variety of answers. When it comes to Real Estate, the most commonly used definition of market value is:
“Market value is the most probable price that a property should bring in a competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale with, the buyer and seller, each acting prudently and knowledgeably, and assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus. Implicit in this definition is the consummation of a sale as of a specified date and the passing of title from seller to buyer under conditions whereby:
buyer and seller are typically motivated;
both parties are well informed or well advised, and each acting in what they consider to be in their own best interest;
a reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market;
payment is made in terms of cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements comparable thereto; and
the price represents the normal consideration for the property sold unaffected by special or creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone associated with the sale.”
This is the definition published by the Federal National Mortgage Association (FNMA), and is the definition the vast majority of mortgage related residential appraisals in the United States are working from.
Of course, there are other types of value, but it’s Market Value we really want, right? This is the all important number that determines our equity, net worth, and American self-esteem. In purchases, it’s what determines whether we’re getting royally shafted, getting the deal of a lifetime, or something in between.
The first part of the FNMA definition above is “probable price”. It does not say is “possible price”. “Probable” infers solid market support, based on past market actions and statistical analysis. Yet, most properties are listed for sale at the absolute highest price possible. The actual sales price tells the story between possible and probable.
Per the Royal Gorge MLS, from 08/01/2026-11/01/2026 the median sales price was $320K for all residential SFR sales in Canon City. The current median list price is $375K, which is a whopping 17% higher. While sellers and agents are keeping their fingers crossed, hoping for a miracle, and pestering poor St Joseph, reality is setting in. As of 11/14/2026 over just the past 72 hours, an astounding 26 listings had price reductions while there were only three total sales. Clearly the ‘possible’ is coming to terms with the ‘probable’ in Canon City and in most national markets.
So what happens when sellers are unwilling or unable to budge, and buyers are increasingly beset with inflation, flat wages, job insecurity, and increasing interest rates?
That’s when we come to the sticky parts of the definition that have to do with parties to the transaction acting prudently and knowledgably without undue stimulus, having been well informed and/or advised, and each acting in their own best interests. All that goes right out the window when a buyer wants what they cannot afford, and everyone involved is willing to do absolutely anything to make it happen.
Just a few years ago, a buyer would get laughed out of the room for demanding seller concessions, presenting an offer one penny less than list price, or for writing a contingent offer (i.e. an offer contingent on the sale of the buyer’s existing home). Contracts were feverishly written with “Appraisal Gap” stipulations, meaning that Market Value meant nothing and buyers were waiving the only the protection they had of getting a fair deal. I actually saw buyers’ agents- BUYERS AGENTS- challenging appraised values as too low, which is a greedy and gross dereliction of duty to their client in all but the most egregious cases of appraiser incompetence.
Things are much different today and Market Value is on the ropes. Combine the prevalence of seller concessions, creative financing (2nd mortgages, adjustable rates, minimal down payments, etc), baked in sales commissions, and now the prevalence of FNMA Appraisal Waivers, the residential housing market in the United States is over-priced by a large margin and continues to elude true affordability for most Americans.
Of major concern lately, MLS systems do not record whether a property had an appraisal waiver, in which the Lender is valuing their own collateral to their liking. This creates statistical ambiguity and the inability for most appraisers to exclude these sales from comparison. Even when an honest and scrupulous appraiser does everything right, if the sales being used as comparable are infected, the result will be sick as well, and the cycle continues.
“Date the Rate, Marry the House”, they’ll say. “Better act quick! Three other people are interested!” The baked cookie scent spray, professional staging and photos, and promises of life happily ever after are an intoxicating invitation to what might be years of fighting off foreclosure and bankruptcy if not handled properly.
Markets have a funny way of self-correcting. Eventually things will normalize, or a zombie apocalypse will spur bidding wars for bunker properties while conforming residential properties become feeding grounds, to later be sold as having ‘good bones’. We’ve all seen the movies. For now though, the scariest creature is not your undead neighbor coming for your brains, but a bad mortgage that will drain you one impossible monthly payment at a time.
If you are in the market, as either a buyer or a seller, a short consultation with an experienced and unbiased appraiser is the way to go. Contact us for a short conversation anytime!